Jun 04, 2025 Leave a message

U.S. Court Of International Trade Blocks Trump's Tariff Policy, Ruling It Is Overreaching

U.S. Court of International Trade blocks Trump's tariff policy, ruling it is overreaching

 

 

 

According to Xinhua News Agency, Beijing, May 29, the United States International Trade Court in New York ruled on the 28th that the Trump administration's package tariff policy was illegal and ordered the revocation of its tariff measures promoted under the International Emergency Economic Powers Act. The Trump administration has appealed. So, what does it mean for the US court to stop the so-called "reciprocal tariffs" and other policies?

Court: Trump's so-called "reciprocal tariffs" are illegal

The United States International Trade Court issued a 49-page ruling on the 28th, prohibiting the Trump administration from implementing the executive order to impose tariffs on multiple countries under the 1977 International Emergency Economic Powers Act.

In February this year, the Trump administration imposed tariffs on Canadian, Mexican and Chinese products exported to the United States in accordance with the International Emergency Economic Powers Act, and on April 2, imposed so-called "reciprocal tariffs" on all trading partners in accordance with the law.

 

U.S. Court of International Trade blocks Trump's tariff policy, ruling it is overreaching

On April 2, US President Trump displayed the signed executive order on the so-called "reciprocal tariffs" at the White House in Washington, D.C. Photo by Xinhua News Agency reporter Hu Yousong According to US media reports, the United States has usually invoked the International Emergency Economic Powers Act to impose sanctions or freeze assets on other countries. Trump is the first US president to invoke this law to impose comprehensive tariffs.

The US International Trade Court held in its ruling that the International Emergency Economic Powers Act does not authorize the president to issue any global tariff orders, retaliatory tariff orders, and tariff orders related to illegal transactions.

The ruling said that the relevant tariff executive orders will be lifted and the execution of these executive orders will be permanently prohibited.

The ruling also stated that if these executive orders are found to be illegal for the plaintiff, these executive orders will be illegal for everyone.

According to US media reports, the White House must complete the procedure for suspending tariff measures within 10 days.

Trump's "tariff card" has been hit

The US International Trade Court is responsible for adjudicating disputes involving international trade, etc., and its rulings can be appealed to the US Federal Court of Appeals and ultimately to the US Supreme Court.

US media analysis said that this ruling is one of the biggest judicial setbacks encountered by the current Trump administration, which is equivalent to completely denying the legal basis for the tariff war during Trump's second term. Once the Trump administration is not allowed to invoke the International Emergency Economic Powers Act, it may have to take a slower approach, that is, to launch lengthy trade investigations based on other trade laws, thereby promoting trade pressure on trading partners.

U.S. Court of International Trade blocks Trump's tariff policy, ruling it is overreaching

This is a photo of containers and trucks taken at the Port of Los Angeles on April 29. Gene Seroka, executive director of the Port of Los Angeles, said on the same day that as the US tariff policy caused companies to cut import orders, the volume of inbound cargo at the Port of Los Angeles next week is expected to fall by more than 35% compared with the same period last year. Xinhua News Agency (Photo by Qiu Chen) Many trade experts believe that the United States has been trying to force its trading partners to make greater compromises through tariff pressure, but the latest ruling will make the ongoing negotiations between the United States and some trading partners more difficult.

Wendy Cutler, director of the Asia Society Policy Institute and a former U.S. trade official, believes that the court ruling has thrown the U.S. government's trade policy into "chaos," and "trading partners that were struggling to advance negotiations during the 90-day tariff suspension period may stop making more concessions to the United States until the U.S. judicial system gives a clearer statement (on the tariff dispute)."

Scott Lincicome, deputy director of the Herbert Stiefel Center for Trade Policy Studies at the Cato Institute, said in a statement: "(The ruling) gives foreign governments important new bargaining chips in trade negotiations."

White House response: Judicial coup

White House spokesman Kush Desai responded on the 28th that the U.S. trade deficit with other countries constitutes a "national emergency that has destroyed American communities, left our workers behind and weakened the defense industrial base," and "how to properly respond to national emergencies should not be decided by unelected judges."

Stephen Miller, deputy director of the White House Office of Staff, wrote on social media: "The judicial coup has gotten out of control."

U.S. Court of International Trade blocks Trump's tariff policy, ruling it is overreaching

According to U.S. media reports, minutes after the U.S. International Trade Court announced its ruling, the Trump administration filed an appeal, questioning the court's power.

U.S. Democrats: Trump administration abuses law

New York Governor Cathy Hochul welcomed the ruling on social media. "We sued the Trump administration over ridiculous tariff policies - we won!" Hochul said, "New York is working to stop these tariffs and put money back in people's pockets."

Gregory Meeks, a senior Democratic member of the U.S. House of Representatives Foreign Affairs Committee, said the ruling confirmed the long-standing consensus that "these tariffs are an illegal abuse of executive power." He said: "Trump's declaration of a false national emergency to justify the global trade war is an absurd and illegal abuse of the International Emergency Economic Powers Act."

There are still five pending tariff lawsuits

The ruling of the U.S. International Trade Court shows that the ruling is against lawsuits filed by five small U.S. businesses and 12 U.S. states against the federal government on April 14 and April 23, respectively.

U.S. Court of International Trade blocks Trump's tariff policy, ruling it is overreaching

On April 19, people participated in a protest in front of the White House in Washington, the capital of the United States. Photo by Xinhua News Agency reporter Hu Yousong. These companies believe that without the approval of Congress, the US government has no right to announce comprehensive tariff measures and demand that the government be prevented from implementing tariff measures in accordance with the International Emergency Economic Powers Act.

In the indictment, 12 US states stated that the Trump administration's tariff policy was "a whim, not a legitimate exercise of legal power" and asked the court to declare the "reciprocal tariff" illegal and prevent its implementation.

According to Reuters, there are at least five lawsuits related to Trump's tariff policy that are currently pending.

Send Inquiry

whatsapp

Phone

E-mail

Inquiry