Two Nickel Alloys, Two Different Design Intentions
C-276 and alloy 625 are often quoted against each other because both are nickel-chromium-molybdenum grades with broadly similar corrosion credentials, and both are stocked in plate, bar, sheet and tube. They are not substitutes, however. C-276 (UNS N10276) was designed around a molybdenum level of about 16% plus 3.0-4.5% tungsten to survive reducing acids and chloride-bearing process streams. Alloy 625 (UNS N06625) was designed around roughly half that molybdenum level plus a niobium addition that makes it strong and creep resistant at high temperature.
Chemistry Side by Side
The table quotes the compositional requirements of ASTM B575 for C-276 plate and ASTM B443 for 625 plate. Bar and rod follow ASTM B574 for C-276 and ASTM B446 for 625; seamless tube follows ASTM B622 and ASTM B444 respectively.
| Element (%) | C-276, UNS N10276 (ASTM B575) | Alloy 625, UNS N06625 (ASTM B443) |
|---|---|---|
| Nickel | Balance, 57.0 min | 58.0 min |
| Chromium | 14.5-16.5 | 20.0-23.0 |
| Molybdenum | 15.0-17.0 | 8.0-10.0 |
| Tungsten | 3.0-4.5 | - |
| Niobium plus tantalum | - | 3.15-4.15 |
| Iron | 4.0-7.0 | 5.0 max |
| Carbon | 0.01 max | 0.10 max |
| Silicon | 0.08 max | 0.50 max |
Two consequences follow from this table. First, C-276 achieves a pitting resistance equivalent number above 70 when calculated as Cr + 3.3(Mo + 0.5W), whereas 625 lands near 50 based on Cr + 3.3Mo. Second, the niobium in 625 forms a strengthening precipitate on thermal exposure, which is why 625 has substantially higher yield strength than C-276 in service and is used for bellows, expansion joints and high-temperature fasteners.
Corrosion Behaviour Compared
Reducing acids. C-276 is the stronger performer. In hydrochloric acid at intermediate concentration and in sulfuric acid below about 60%, the higher molybdenum and tungsten content keeps corrosion rates low. Alloy 625 corrodes faster in these media, particularly as acid concentration and temperature rise.
Oxidizing and mixed acids. Alloy 625 closes the gap and can be superior. Its higher chromium content supports a more stable passive film in nitric acid and in nitric-hydrofluoric mixtures, and it resists oxidation at temperatures where C-276 begins to form volatile oxides.
Chloride pitting and crevice attack. C-276 has the higher critical pitting temperature in ferric chloride testing per ASTM G48, so it is preferred for seawater-cooled equipment and for chloride-contaminated process lines where crevices cannot be eliminated.
Sour service. Both grades are used in oil and gas production under NACE MR0175 / ISO 15156, with acceptance depending on the partial pressure of hydrogen sulfide, chloride level, temperature and hardness of the finished component.
Mechanical Properties and Elevated Temperature
C-276 in the annealed condition is relatively soft, with typical tensile strength around 790 MPa and yield strength around 355 MPa, and it is selected for corrosion duty rather than for load carrying. Alloy 625 in the annealed condition typically reaches about 855 MPa tensile and 415 MPa yield, and in the stress-relieved condition used for tubing it holds strength to higher metal temperatures. Alloy 625 is also more resistant to fatigue and has better low-cycle fatigue life, which matters in bellows and flexible pipe. In the 600 to 800 degrees Celsius band, 625 maintains useful creep strength while C-276 is limited to roughly 675 degrees Celsius continuous service.
Fabrication and Welding
Both alloys are welded with matching filler and both are tolerant of the as-welded condition in most services, since neither relies on a post-weld anneal to restore corrosion resistance in the heat-affected zone. C-276 requires stricter housekeeping: the surface oxide formed during welding must be removed because embedded oxide particles become pitting initiation sites, and contamination from carbon steel tooling must be avoided. Alloy 625 is slightly easier to machine at equivalent hardness, although both work-harden quickly and need low surface speed with heavy, continuous feed. Cold forming of C-276 above about 15% reduction calls for a subsequent solution anneal at 1120-1150 degrees Celsius; 625 retains more ductility and generally tolerates greater cold reduction without heat treatment.
Which Grade to Buy
Choose C-276 for hydrochloric and sulfuric acid equipment, chloride-bearing streams, seawater piping and heat exchangers with crevices, and where the specification names NACE MR0175 / ISO 15156 for sour service. Choose alloy 625 where strength at temperature governs, where oxidizing acids dominate, or where fatigue life and resistance to oxidation above 700 degrees Celsius matter, such as gas turbine ducting, exhaust systems, and flexible expansion elements. Where the two overlap, the deciding factor is usually the corrodent chemistry: molybdenum-rich handles reducing conditions, chromium-rich handles oxidizing conditions.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Can C-276 and 625 be used in the same welded assembly?
A: Yes, provided the welding procedure is qualified for the specific combination. Nickel-based filler of the higher alloy content is usually selected, and the galvanic couple between the two is small because both alloys passivate in the same media.
Q: Which grade is better in seawater?
A: C-276, because its higher molybdenum plus tungsten content gives a higher critical pitting and crevice temperature. Alloy 625 performs well in flowing seawater but is more vulnerable under deposits and in tight crevices.
Q: Is alloy 625 magnetic?
A: It is essentially non-magnetic in the annealed condition. Cold working raises permeability slightly, which matters for instrumentation components that must remain magnetically transparent.
Q: What is the maximum service temperature of each grade?
A: C-276 is normally limited to about 675 degrees Celsius in continuous service because of oxidation and long-term phase stability. Alloy 625 is used to roughly 815 degrees Celsius for oxidation resistance and retains useful strength at that level.
Q: Does 625 need a post-weld heat treatment?
A: Not for corrosion service. In heavy sections, a stress relief may be specified to restore ductility and reduce residual stress, but the alloy is not sensitized by welding and the heat-affected zone retains its corrosion resistance.
Q: Which grade is more readily available in large diameters?
A: C-276 is commonly stocked in plate and heavy bar and is produced in seamless pipe to ASTM B622 in a wide size range. Alloy 625 is widely available in sheet, tube and bar, and large forged rings are produced to ASTM B564.





