Nov 06, 2024 Leave a message

Five Key Differences Between Inconel and Hastelloy Alloys

Buyers often treat Inconel and Hastelloy as two names for the same class of material and ask for the cheaper one. They are different families with different chemistry strategies, and choosing the wrong one usually shows up as pitting, crevice attack or premature high temperature degradation rather than as an immediate failure at commissioning.

1. Chemistry Families Are Different

The Inconel group is a nickel-chromium family. Alloy 625, UNS N06625, contains a minimum of about 58 percent nickel with roughly 20.0 to 23.0 percent chromium, 8.0 to 10.0 percent molybdenum and 3.15 to 4.15 percent niobium plus tantalum, the niobium being what gives the grade its strength through the formation of gamma double prime precipitates. Alloy 718, UNS N07718, is a precipitation-hardening grade with about 50.0 to 55.0 percent nickel, 17.0 to 21.0 percent chromium, 4.75 to 5.50 percent niobium plus tantalum and 2.80 to 3.30 percent molybdenum, hardened by additions of titanium and aluminium. The Hastelloy group is a nickel-molybdenum family in which chromium is either absent or present in much smaller amounts. C-276, UNS N10276, contains about 14.5 to 16.5 percent chromium, 15.0 to 17.0 percent molybdenum, 3.0 to 4.5 percent tungsten and 4.0 to 7.0 percent iron, with carbon limited to a very low level to avoid grain boundary carbide precipitation after welding. The B family goes further, being essentially nickel-molybdenum with almost no chromium, and is used where reducing acids attack chromium-bearing alloys.

Alloy Family Core composition Design intent
625, UNS N06625 Nickel-chromium-molybdenum-niobium Chromium 20.0 - 23.0 percent, molybdenum 8.0 - 10.0 percent, niobium plus tantalum 3.15 - 4.15 percent Oxidising and mixed media, high temperature oxidation resistance
718, UNS N07718 Precipitation hardening nickel-chromium Chromium 17.0 - 21.0 percent, niobium plus tantalum 4.75 - 5.50 percent, titanium and aluminium High strength at temperature, aerospace and oilfield hardware
C-276, UNS N10276 Nickel-molybdenum-chromium Molybdenum 15.0 - 17.0 percent, tungsten 3.0 - 4.5 percent, chromium 14.5 - 16.5 percent Severely corrosive chemical media including chlorides

2. They Resist Different Media

The practical dividing line is oxidising versus reducing conditions. Chromium content drives resistance to oxidising acids and to high temperature oxidation, and that is where the Inconel grades are strong. Molybdenum content drives resistance to reducing acids and to chloride pitting and crevice attack, and that is where the Hastelloy grades are strong. C-276 with 15 to 17 percent molybdenum plus tungsten is designed for aggressive mixed acid and chloride environments, and it resists pitting and crevice corrosion far better than 625 in chloride service. Conversely, in strongly oxidising conditions and in high temperature air, the higher chromium content of 625 provides better protection. Selection should therefore start from the actual process stream: acid type and concentration, chloride level, oxidiser content, temperature and the presence of crevices.

3. High Temperature Behaviour Differs

Alloy 625 is used where oxidation resistance and creep strength are needed at high temperature, and it retains useful strength to roughly 700 degrees Celsius and oxidation resistance in continuous service approaching 1000 degrees Celsius in clean air. Alloy 718 is the workhorse when high strength must be retained at temperature, with an aged tensile strength in the region of 1240 MPa and a yield strength in the region of 1035 MPa, values far above the annealed bar properties of 625, which are around 827 MPa tensile and 414 MPa minimum yield. The Hastelloy C-276 grade is not a high temperature strength alloy; it is selected for corrosion, and its mechanical properties are modest, in the region of 690 MPa tensile and 283 MPa yield in the annealed condition. Standard specifications follow the same split, with 625 and 718 covered for bar and rod by ASTM B446 and for pipe by ASTM B444 and ASTM B622 respectively, while C-276 plate, sheet and strip are covered by ASTM B575.

4. Fabrication and Welding Behaviour Diverge

Both families weld successfully, but the procedures are not interchangeable. C-276 requires low heat input and clean conditions because its corrosion resistance depends on keeping carbon and intermetallic precipitation under control in the weld zone, and post-weld solution annealing is generally avoided by limiting heat input instead. Alloy 718 is normally welded in the solution treated condition and then aged, since the aging treatment itself relieves stresses and restores strength in the weld; welding in the aged condition is avoided. Alloy 625 is weldable in the annealed condition with matching filler and is often used as a welding consumable for other alloys. Machining follows the same pattern: 718 is difficult to machine in the aged state, while the austenitic 625 and C-276 work harden and require rigid setups, low speeds and generous feed to get under the work-hardened layer.

5. Cost, Availability and Specification Drivers

Cost tracks nickel, molybdenum and tungsten content. C-276 carries both the highest molybdenum level and a tungsten addition, which makes it the most expensive of the three per kilogramme in most markets, while 625 sits below it and 718 is priced on the basis of its alloy content and the heat treatment route. Availability also matters: 625 and 718 are produced in a wide range of bar, plate, pipe and forging forms, whereas the most highly alloyed corrosion grades have a narrower product range and longer lead times. Where a project is subject to sour service requirements, the material must additionally satisfy NACE MR0175, which is issued jointly as ISO 15156 for the oil and gas industry and imposes hardness limits and heat treatment restrictions that can eliminate some otherwise suitable grades. The correct approach is to fix the environment, then select from the standards that cover the required product form rather than choosing by family name.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Is Inconel or Hastelloy more corrosion resistant?
A: Neither is universally better. Chromium-rich Inconel grades perform better in oxidising media and in high temperature air, while molybdenum-rich Hastelloy C-276 performs better in reducing acids and in chloride-bearing media where pitting and crevice corrosion are the risk.

Q: Can 625 and C-276 be substituted for each other?
A: Only after checking the process chemistry, temperature and crevice conditions. Substituting 625 for C-276 in a chloride-heavy stream risks pitting, and substituting C-276 for 625 in a strongly oxidising or high temperature oxidising service risks accelerated attack.

Q: Which one is stronger at high temperature?
A: Of the three common grades, 718 is strongest after aging, with tensile strength in the region of 1240 MPa, followed by annealed 625 at around 827 MPa. C-276 is selected for corrosion resistance rather than elevated temperature strength.

Q: Are these alloys suitable for sour service?
A: They are commonly used in sour oil and gas service, but the finished components must meet NACE MR0175, issued jointly as ISO 15156, which sets hardness limits and heat treatment requirements by material type. Compliance should be confirmed for the specific product form and condition.

Q: How do the applicable standards differ by product form?
A: Nickel-chromium-molybdenum-niobium bar and rod such as 625 and 718 falls under ASTM B446, pipe under ASTM B444 and ASTM B622, and forgings under ASTM B564, while C-276 plate, sheet and strip are covered by ASTM B575 and matching pipe by ASTM B622.

Q: Why does C-276 have a much lower carbon limit?
A: The very low carbon level limits the precipitation of molybdenum-rich grain boundary phases during welding and thermal exposure, which preserves corrosion resistance in the heat-affected zone. That is also why controlled welding procedures are essential for the grade.

Send Inquiry

whatsapp

Phone

E-mail

Inquiry